by Michael Ettinger, Esq.
Commonly used in estate planning today, disclaimer trusts allow the surviving spouse great flexibility in optimizing estate tax savings.
Here’s how they work. Each spouse sets up their revocable living trust. Husband and wife are co-trustees of his trust, using his social security number and, similarly, they are both co-trustees of her trust with her social security number. Let’s say husband dies first. His trust says “leave everything to my wife except that, whatever she disclaims, i.e. refuses to take, will remain in my trust. The disclaimer is a legal document that lists the assets disclaimed and their value. Wife remains as trustee on husband’s trust after he dies and may use the funds in his trust for her health, maintenance and support. She may also remove 5% of the trust every year for any reason or $5,000, whichever is greater.
The reason wife is limited to health, maintenance and support is that, if she had the right to take whatever she wanted at any time for any reason, the IRS would say that she had complete control of the funds and would then seek to tax those funds in her estate. The access for health, maintenance and support, however, is sufficiently broad so as not to cause a problem for her. She may also continue to buy, sell and trade assets in the husband’s trust. This trust continues for her lifetime and pays out to the heirs at her death along with her own trust.
Husband’s social security number died with him so his trust took out a trust tax identification number when he died and reported as a separate taxpayer during her lifetime. It is not includable in her estate. Indeed, what has happened is that husband’s trust was settled on his death and left to his heirs, but subject to wife’s lifetime use and enjoyment of the trust assets.
The benefit of the disclaimer is that it allows the wife to decide (or the husband if wife dies first) how much to leave in the deceased spouse’s trust based on her age, health and the tax laws at that future time. Formerly, attorneys would simply do their best to split the assets between the two trusts and simply say whatever was in the deceased spouse’s trust remained there for the surviving spouse’s lifetime. This yielded some unfortunate results.
Let’s say husband’s trust had over one million dollars but the tax exempt amount was one million even (as it currently is in New York State). Formerly, wife would be required to pay tens of thousands of dollars in estate tax based on the amount over one million. With the disclaimer trust, wife may take the excess over one million out of his trust for herself and claim the unlimited marital deduction which avoids estate tax on assets left to a spouse. Perhaps her estate will be under one million dollars and no taxes will ever have to be paid on that money, she may spend it down under one million during her lifetime or the exemption may be raised during her lifetime. In any event, worst case scenario is that taxes on those monies are deferred until after she dies and, in the meantime, she has the use and enjoyment of monies that would have formerly gone to the government.